Leaders are surprised by uncertainty. When we were young, we knew “how we would do it” if we ever became the leader. But many leaders find that they have less certainty today than they did before. Their days are full of foggy, ambiguous, and complicated decisions.
We believed that if our authority grew our certainty in our decisions would grow with it (perhaps we also assumed that more certainty would lead to more authority!). Did you ever used to think:
- “Once it’s my turn, we’ll make the changes that are long overdue.”
- “I’ll have the guts to cut programs and people that aren’t effective.”
- “The answer is obvious! Either the leaders can’t see it or they just won’t do it.”
This thinking is normal. Problems usually look clearer from far away. Most leaders experience that the opposite of this true. As authority goes up, certainty often goes down.
Complex problems float up. You and your leadership team are facing difficult, nuanced and consequential choices.
Your reward for solving a complex, ambiguous, or sticky problem today is a new one tomorrow. Maybe you miss the days when the problems had lower stakes, repeatable solutions, or less people waiting on you.
Ambiguity is tiring. Certainty feels familiar. And so, leaders often find themselves allowing their time, meetings, and attention to drift toward the familiar. We default to work that feels certain. The trouble is: certain work doesn’t need your level of authority! If you only work on what feels solvable and certain, you’ll find that eventually people think they need your authority to solve anything!
Leaders become the bottleneck for decisions when they insert themselves back into decisions that didn’t need their authority.
Imagine work is divided into quadrants.
- This is where leaders need to live. Questions here are complex, nuanced, and need authority.
- Leaders often drift here. It feels good to flex our authority to solve things and move things along.
- But when we do, we limit people who should live in box 3. We become their ceiling (and then get frustrated at them for taking up all our time!)
- This is where managers end up if direction is unclear.
So, what do we do? First: Make the leap to box 1 and invite others to join you. It will feel like you are crossing a chasm from the land of the familiar to the land of the fog. Do it anyway.
Your organization or team is going to have complex questions. Who else would you want to wrestle through them? Remind the people with you that your meetings should stay in box 1. Ask yourself, “What does the rest of the organization hope we get clarity about?” You might talk about leadership this way, reminding your leaders (and aspiring leaders) that more authority means less permission to work on the familiar. We have to work on what they organization needs us to. We’re the only ones here who can live in box 1.
Second: Name who lives in box 3 and try to stay out of their way. Get used to saying, “You decide.” If it seems like your managers are living in box 4 (that is, they aren’t making great consistent decisions), then do the work to clarify processes, decision-rights, and decision-filters.
If you feel uncertain, chances are you are in the right room. The less you know, the more you may be needed. Uncertainty isn’t a sign you’re a bad leader, it may be a sign you’re doing the work they need you to.