Third Space

Resources · Decisions

Who Decides?

Three characteristics of teams with clear decision rights.

By Beau Johnson · 7 min read

Most organizations need to re-clarify who does what and who decides what. This is especially true when you are growing, changing, or have added several members to the team.

A lack of decision rights leads to people bumping into each other (or dropping the ball). Most people will be gracious the first few times. But after a few bruises, it’s time to re-clarify decision rights.

Decide who decides

Leaders have to decide who decides. The first step for a founder or CEO is to get out of the center of every decision. Startups often have a hub and spoke approach, with a leader in the middle directing traffic. Eventually, that leader becomes a bottleneck for decisions and progress.

The organization must shift. The leader must lead the team, but the team leads the organization.

Leaders: There is no one else in the organization who can provide role and decision clarity. Don’t leave it up to your team to figure it out on their own.

Team One

A team-led organization means the team members must shift from approaching their work like one of the spokes to overseeing the whole. We call this “Team One.” This doesn’t mean you are more important than everyone else, it does mean when you show up to this team you are the ones who think first about the organization (not just about the people you lead).

For Team One to operate effectively, they have to willingly embrace the tension that they must be responsible for an area without being territorial about it. While I take responsibility for sales, I don’t silo or shelter my team from the organization. I won’t resist input into my area from someone who understands it less. While I am ultimately accountable for my team, I am also responsible for the success of the whole.

Note to the leader: If you’re picking people to be on Team One, look for people who are willing to live in this tension. If someone is unwilling or unable to think about the whole, they will be frustrated and create division.

While it may be clear who leads what area, there will be many decisions that impact multiple teams. How do we know who decides what? How can we move fast and stay aligned? How do we know what to fix on our own and what to do together? When we are stuck, who breaks the tie?

Organizations that make fast, accurate, and aligned decisions have these three things in common.

1. They use organizational clarity to make decisions.

Most of the time when a team is asking who gets to decide, they are revealing a gap in how we decide. They want to know who can decide to move quickly. Quick decisions can just get us out of alignment quickly.

While you never want your decisions to violate your mission or values, the most common way you should be talking about decisions is through your strategy. Whether you call these Strategic Anchors, Big Bets, or your Hedgehog Concept, everyone on Team One should be using the same decision-making filters. Your organizational clarity should be your go-to answer to the question, “Wait, how did you decide?”

Note to the leaders: As often as you can, interpret your decisions for your team. Talk about your decisions through the lens of your values, your strategy, your mission, or your priorities. It’s okay to use your gut, but put a few sentences of explanation around what was in your gut.

2. They slow down to go fast.

Most leaders hate going slow. Good news: you can go fast almost all the time. If you slow down in these three instances, you’ll avoid endless back-tracking and be able to go faster the rest of the time.

The first 10%. Trajectory gets set in the first 10% of the work. This is where we clarify the problem we are solving and our intended direction. If we’re off here, we’ll certainly be off later. The first 10% of a project is also a great time for the point leader to clarify who makes decisions along the way and how often they want to hear updates. They may say:

  • I’ll decide
  • We’ll decide, or
  • You decide

When it impacts others. You know in your gut when you should pick up the phone. If you’re making a decision that impacts someone’s team: involve them. Start with the problem, address how you believe it will impact them and the organization, and ask for their input. If you get stuck, raise it with the leadership team together.

Tip: When you’re seeking input, clarify if you are soliciting their voice, vote, or veto. You might be asking for their input, perspective, or thoughts (that’s their voice). While we shouldn’t default to voting for decision-making, it’s sometimes helpful to get a pulse check on whether they’d go. Or, you might clarify that this is where you are going, but if someone wants to raise a red flag (a veto) this is the time to do it.

Quarterly recalibration. The faster you go, the more often you need to adjust course. Nobody feels they have time to get offsite for a day or two. But when you do, you’ll re-enter faster and more aligned. Use time ~quarterly to check on the progress of your strategy, get aligned about priorities, and discuss the topics you never get around to.

Tip: Give time at least once a year to redefine roles. What you are accountable for should define what you need to make decisions about. Let each team member say what they believe they are responsible for, what their priority is, how we’ll know they are on track, and what needs attention from Team One.

3. They don’t get their feelings hurt.

The slowest way to make a decision is by consensus. Organizations without clear decision rights end up asking their best leaders to play corporate politics, building and gathering consensus with constant give-and-take. Consensus leads to slow and tepid decisions that were unevenly influenced by the loudest voices. Don’t do that.

Let people lead. Empower them to have a bias toward action. Yes, they’ll occasionally step on toes, forget to bring someone in, or communicate imperfectly. Don’t let hurt feelings veto good decisions. A telltale sign that you’ve tolerated this is when people complain about being out of the loop more than they complain about indecision, bad decisions, or inattention to results.

Healthy competent leaders are glad when other people make decisions! They like movement. They know a bicycle is actually more stable when it’s moving.

Decide who decides, then let them.

Discussion questions

  1. Where are we running into each other right now, and who should own that decision?
  2. Are we pausing often enough as a team?
  3. What is one decision we made recently that we never explained? How would we explain it now using our strategy?

These words are my own. AI helped me research, proofread, and design. Beau Johnson, 2026

Back to resources

Find your group.

If you want to stop leading alone, joining a cohort is the right decision.

Join a cohort

From $475 a month. Cancel anytime.